Home Affairs wins Constitutional Court case against repeat asylum applications

Tuesday, May 12, 2026

The Department of Home Affairs has secured a significant victory against the abuse of the asylum system following a judgment handed down by the Constitutional Court in Director-General, Department of Home Affairs and Others v Irankunda and Another. 

In its majority ruling, the apex court upheld the department’s appeal against an earlier ruling from the Supreme Court of Appeal by confirming that repeat asylum applications are not permitted once an original application has been finally determined. 

In a statement issued on Tuesday, the department said the judgment marks another major step in its efforts to clamp down on abuse of the asylum system and restore the rule of law in the broader management of immigration and refugee matters. 

The ruling, which prohibits endless repeat applications by asylum seekers whose original applications have been rejected, comes just weeks after Cabinet approved the Revised White Paper on Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection. 

The policy introduces the first-safe-country principle aimed at ending the practice of asylum seekers “picking and choosing” South Africa as their preferred destination in the region. 

According to the department, the recent breakthroughs demonstrate that the department is making rapid progress in rebuilding these systems from the ground up to better serve South Africa’s interests. 

“This judgment from the highest court in the land is an affirmation of the unprecedented progress we are making in restoring the rule of law and clamping down on abuse in the migration and asylum systems. It further demonstrates that our commitment to systemic reform - not in opposition to but anchored in our Constitution - is rapidly resolving problems that once seemed insurmountable,” Home Affairs Minister, Dr Leon Schreiber, said.  – SAnews.gov.za